Top Groups

Discussions

GROUP HISTORY

I will update this weekly

4/7/19:
1 Member
1 Discussion
Group is created today! Woohoo! *confetti and stuff falls from sky*

4/15/19:
8 Members
2 Discussions
Eek! I forgot to do this yesterday. The group is already dying, so uhh… :o
@Jaybird1 is one of the first truly active members, I told him I would give him a shoutout here, so here you go :P

4/26/19:
14 Members
3 Discussions
I haven't updated this in a while, this group is blowing up now...

4/30/19:
22 Members
5 Discussions
Holy cow, this group is blowing up. 8 members in 4 days, wow...

5/13/19:
30 Members
4 Discussions
Hmm...Starting to die again...

5/16/19
35 Members
5 Discussions
Welp...I was wrong...

5/17/19
41 Members
7 Discussions
I was very wrong, this group is really blowing up, welp

5/18/19
47 Members
7 Discussions
Again, welp

5/22/19
55 Members
8 Discussions
So I had to kick a member (Indy500) for spamming a link to an unsecure website. Sorry, but spam for no purpose is not tolerated. 

5/29/19
70 Members
11 Discussions
Okay then, I don't know what to say

5/30/19
72 Members
12 Discussions
Okay then, I started a discussion trying to get to 1k comments, and I thought it would fail. As I am writing this, Lizzapie, Mnmwert, Vash Hartman, and myself are spamming to get it to 1k. It's already at like 150 or something (every 2 minutes I refresh and I have 10+ notifications lol)

5/31/19
83 Members
14 Discussions
So this group is now closing in on 100 members, but we need more discussions!

6/1/19
95 Members
18 Discussions
Wow, 5 more members till 100! 

6/2/19
100 Members
20 Discussions
Woohoo! 100 Members!

6/8/19
113 Members
34 Discussions
This group is starting to die

6/18/19
35 Discussions
123 Members
Now the member count has capped out at around 1 member per day, BUT this is a random group, and I didn't really expect it to be this active.

6/29/19
36 Discussions
129 Members
I'm just going to leave this group alone for a while, only update this discussion every once in a while.

Help needed

 Hi everyone :)So I need to choose my best rondo I composed for practicing it in my summer holiday (I know sometimes composers don^t know how to play their own pieces) so I need your help. All 3 rondos are in my profile but I will leave the links here for easy access. Thanks to all the people who read this and helped me:) Love you all <3  
https://musescore.com/dozin2/grand-rondo-alla-turca-op-1
https://musescore.com/dozin2/rondo_g_major
https://musescore.com/dozin2/rondo
 

A statistical ode to BSG

I have been curious about some basic statistics on this community for a while, like at least let me sort the scores in this group by views, comments or favorites! But also, how many comments are there, by whom, who is most favored, what are some popular pieces from years ago? So with disregard for my own safety I downloaded all scores in this group (just the plain html page, no music of any kind) and did some counting!

Fun story before we get to the numbers. I did a back of the envelope calculation on how much I would torture the musescore servers, and it's about 4000 requests totalling about 150MB, this is also known in professional circles as not-a-lot™ but after downloading the data musescore IP blocked me. I'm now posting this over a VPN.

Counterpoint & Fugue has 2227 scores posted by 193 users, those that post most works in Counterpoint & Fugue:
627 verits99
260 BSG
151 Clarin Pardo
113 dmanzana
 79 schoutens
 63 Roland Bouman
 56 Simon Lecaulle
 51 Arthur Stammet
 40 bump
 39 Riccardo Collu
 33 timothyser2
 32 SDG
 28 boblucassen
 27 Darius237
 25 H. Gürtler

Verits99 has so many as he posted a massive amount of works by Bach, thank you Verits. BSG is more quality over quantity but is a clear runner up. But this is only the start of this stories ode to BSG. It's interesting to see how this list shifts as we count total favorites, which correlates with scores but is not like it:

1677 verits99        2.67 favs/score
1628 BSG             6.26 favs/score
 753 Clarin Pardo    4.99 favs/score
 344 schoutens       4.35 favs/score
 253 Roland Bouman   4.02 favs/score
 237 Riccardo Collu  6.08 favs/score
 173 timothyser2     5.24 favs/score
 152 SDG             4.75 favs/score
 144 H. H. Maung     12.00 favs/score
 138 Arthur Stammet  2.71 favs/score
 129 Ruslan Denshaev 6.45 favs/score
 106 Simon Lecaulle  1.89 favs/score
 106 michaelcbro     5.05 favs/score
  99 dmanzana        0.88 favs/score

Additionally there are 6634 comments by 187 users:
2827 BSG
 447 Clarin Pardo
 221 schoutens
 212 dmanzana
 194 verits99
 183 thementalhandle
 169 boblucassen
 151 cadams
 131 SDG
 121 penne vodka
 
BSG is clearly a very important part of this community, but to put his impact into real perspective we need to look at the word count:
114,362 BSG
 10,712 boblucassen
  8,168 Clarin Pardo
  6,392 schoutens
  5,915 SDG
  5,798 penne vodka
  5,722 verits99
  5,093 cadams
  3,098 dmanzana
  3,068 thementalhandle
  
Staggering... that's literally a books worth & more words than all other commenters combined by a wide margin (53966 words) and this does not even count his tutorials and essays. Also, I never realized I talk so much, I hope you guys don't mind.

Now I also want to make a list of 'good' scores in C&F, we can simply look by favourites but I think we should weigh the importance of those favourites as some are worth more than others. Let's say that a user is valued when many of his scores have favorites by other valued users, I realize that this sounds a little incestious but it works perfectly well ;).

Here are some people who's works are liked by well-liked people, the 'score' is a is relative measure
12 BSG
11 cadams
10 Riccardo Collu
10 timothyser2
7 schoutens
7 Roland Bouman
7 Tonsetzer
6 MC_M4hl0r
5 H. H. Maung
5 Clarin Pardo
4 SDG
4 boblucassen

And now we can list all scores in Counterpoint & Fugue by this metric,  and find some works that perhaps we forgot about. I tried to filter out Bach's works and those would dominate so if I accidentally removed an original composition I apologize.

Now of the first 10 works 8 are by BSG so to make the list a bit more varied, here are first 10 works by BSG ordered by the above metric, and then we'll follow with the non-BSG list
BSG                  Fuga (di BSG 19.03.15), at Hauptwerk/Grabowski Giubiasco https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/5490443
BSG                  Fuga 05-15-2018 (di BSG) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/5097926
BSG                  Il Contrappunto Barocco, il secondo libro (Ch. V-VI) (attempted BSG “book” inprogress) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/5146471
BSG                  Cembalo-Konzert d moll, I, Allegro (di BSG, 1999-2000) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/1124521
BSG                  Tutorial: Linear Targeted Motion (BSG 2019) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/5606541
BSG                  3 Kings per canonem (di BSG 2018) (re-recorded on Hauptwerk/Sonus Doesburg) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/5278189
BSG                  So ist mein Jesus nun gebunden (Aria di BSG, 1981) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/924986
BSG                  Canon ad nonam super ‘Lamento’ (di BSG 2016) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/2442076
BSG                  Cembalo-Konzert d moll, II, Siciliano (di BSG, 2001)(new in MS3 with someartic. fixups) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/1135136
BSG                  Pièce d'Orgue (di BSG, 2017) (performed on Sonus Paradisi Doesburg) https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/3889661

And the rest of us! I left it at one piece per composer.
Tonsetzer            (Triple) Fugue a 4 voc. in f minor https://musescore.com/user/39102/scores/5243863
timothyser2          Arie - "O Tochter Zion, freue dich!" https://musescore.com/user/3365821/scores/2975181
Niilo Korsulainen    Symphony No. 2 D major Op. 24 https://musescore.com/user/212006/scores/2041221
piotr.a              Prelude and fugue in G major https://musescore.com/user/14787961/scores/5368587
cadams               Concerto for Viola Mvt 4 https://musescore.com/user/18579/scores/5141873
H. H. Maung          Six Fugues https://musescore.com/user/6707006/scores/1613931
atmaninov            prelude & fugue in C minor https://musescore.com/user/23479051/scores/5130623
Riccardo Collu       Variations on Haendel's Passacaglia for Wind Quartet https://musescore.com/user/205067/scores/1830301
MC_M4hl0r            Chorale Prelude on "Wer nur den lieben Gott lässt walten" https://musescore.com/user/4156301/scores/1939051
Eleazart 2           Fugetta en D menor para piano https://musescore.com/user/28657702/scores/5098089
el-russo             Fugue D moll https://musescore.com/user/41695/scores/3793941
schoutens            Suite in D minor for Oboe and Piano (Opus 29) https://musescore.com/user/54471/scores/164290
Joost-k              Prelude & Fuga à3 (for guitar solo) https://musescore.com/user/27184143/scores/4902608
waszil               Trio Sonata Op. 1. No. 3 https://musescore.com/user/4900541/scores/3205036
mw119                Sonata in D flat major Op 7 No 1 https://musescore.com/user/27095571/scores/4848906
Clarin Pardo         Schumann: Studien für den Pedalflügel, Sechs Stücke in kanonischer Form, Op.56/1 https://musescore.com/user/84251/scores/4318241
David L Dinh         Poor People of Paris (piano arr.) https://musescore.com/user/19233641/scores/5576305
Roland Bouman        Flows - for reed quintet https://musescore.com/user/67638/scores/5468238
Timon de Nood        Flute Sonatina in A major https://musescore.com/user/14593126/scores/5172331
boblucassen          Fugue in G minor https://musescore.com/user/6168221/scores/5386975

Don't read too much into this (apart from the BSG bit), I'm just playing around and there are some problems, like being unable to correct for the beneficial effect of posting in many groups, or correcting properly for posting many works but I still had fun and hope you enjoyed getting some insight into our community.

Thinking of making a separate account for symphonies

So, I have been planning out my first symphony. I gave it the nickname "The War Symphony". It still isn't flushed out yet but I have decided to have it be a programmatic symphony with this movement structure:

First Movement:

Key: Bb major
Aspect: Battle
Form: Sonata Form

Second Movement:

Key: F minor
Aspect: Death
Form: Not decided on yet but I'm leaning towards ternary form

Third Movement:

Key: Not decided on
Aspect: Battle again
Form: Scherzo and Trio

Finale:

Key: Bb major
Aspect: Victory
Form: Sonata-Rondo Form

The first movement is what I have flushed out the most out of all the movements so far in my plans so obviously, that will be the part I work on first. But I'm wondering, since I can't really afford a Pro membership(maybe a few years down the line I will be able to afford it but I can't currently), should I make a separate account to put my symphony score on once it is finished? And if so, should that account be just for my symphonies if I happen to want to compose more than 1 symphony?

Heads-up: This group was featured!

Hi, everyone! Just so you know, Competitions, Collaboration, and Creations was recently featured in the Group of Group's list for competition groups! If you  want to talk about your experience as a member of this group, or give  more info to those considering joining, head on over the Group of  Groups.(
https://musescore.com/groups/group-of-groups/discuss/5042554

We look forward to seeing you!

What if I would post this?

I'm currently working on two transcriptions for one hand (3 actually, but the third is paused currently):

1. Mazeppa (S.137)
2. Grande Valse Brilliante (Op. 34 no. 1)
3. Nocturne Op. Posthum in C-Minor

All these are pieces by famous composers transcribed for one hand...
Could I share those in this group?

Also, could I share my exact copies of the Douze Grandes Ètudes S. 137
(which I'm currently working on)?

Thx in advance,
Robin Pannenberg