Top Groups


742 discussions • 8.7K scores • 54.7K members


Feedback request

A feedback request for a composition of mine (the core concept dates mid 90s, I've added some finishing touches this year):

I wonder which year of piano education could this possibly fit? Would you, as a piano teacher, give this to your student?

Few other ideas wait but a constructive feedback from piano players could possibly help me in avoiding possible pitfalls I ocassionally could bump into without proper piano background (I lack this).

Also, general comments on the composing style are welcomed. Thanks in advance.

For the piano virtuoso writers! I need help finishing this project

 I'm currently doing a collection of pieces in all 24 keys, for piano solo. I need help completing the set, so I'd appreciate it if you'd help out composing a short (less than or around 4 minutes) in G# minor (for now). The only criteria it must fulfill in order for it to be considered in the project is that the style of the piece must be different from the rest. Example: the piece in F major is written in a waltz, the one in Eb major is written 4/4 against 3/4, C minor has a Prokofiev (I think) feel to it, F minor is written in jazz, etc. Also, it must show some form of virtuoso/impressionism (whichever you are aiming for). I am interested in the dances forms (tango, marzuka, minuet, sarabande...), but anything goes for now. Credits will be given for the piece if it makes it in, as well as a favourite and a follow, very well deserving.

Here's the piece:

PS: I might reject some pieces if I find the piece unsuitable for the project, I'll also include critique/reasons for the said decision. Love to hear from you guys!