Sergei Rachmaninoff had very big hands. He could cover chords that beat the regular large-handed pianists, and the clearest account comes from one who tried to match him. Cyril Smith, an English pianist whose hands each spanned a twelfth, admitted Rachmaninoff’s were the largest he’d seen, and that they “covered the keyboard like octopus tentacles.”

Rachmaninoff’s Right-Hand Chord That Even Cyril Smith Couldn’t Play

There’s a left-hand chord attributed to Sergei Rachmaninoff: C, E-flat, G, C, G. Cyril Smith could manage it, but he couldn’t match the right hand. The right-hand chord ran C with the second finger, then E, G, C, and E with the thumb tucked under.

Smith called the feat of playing it both likely unique and scarcely credible. As D.A.B. Young described on BMJ, the thumb-under stretch is at nine inches, and requires not just hand size, but also extraordinary flexibility. A twelfth, an octave plus a perfect fifth, is the span usually credited to the Russian composer. Smith could span a twelfth too, yet the right-hand chord covers only a tenth. What beat him was the thumb crossing under to reach the top E, which takes extensibility more than raw size.

The BMJ article reproduced the opening of Piano Concerto No. 2 in C minor, Op. 18, with a caption explaining that the chords are rarely performed as written. Most players either split them or partly break them.

The danger comes during the poco a poco crescendo, when an overextended hand can miss. Young also pointed to the final prelude of Op. 32, the Prelude in D-flat major, as containing chords that require great extensibility.

Did Rachmaninoff Have Marfan Syndrome? D.A.B. Young’s Theory

Young, formerly a principal scientist at the Wellcome Foundation, suggested that Rachmaninoff’s hand size and extensibility indicate he had Marfan syndrome. Additional evidence included the composer’s height (193 cm), slender build, a narrow head and long nose in photographs, probable myopia, and a clenched thumb extending well past the edge of the hand.

He conceded that harder findings, such as lens dislocation and aortic dilation, are required for a proper diagnosis, rather than the soft features of his argument, and that Rachmaninoff seems to have been free of any cardiovascular indications.

Acromegaly: The Counter-Diagnosis for Rachmaninoff’s Hands

Ramachandran and Aronson answered in 2006. They wrote that hand size and slenderness could fit Marfan-type arachnodactyly, but noted that Sergei Rachmaninoff showed no clear scoliosis, pectus excavatum, or eye or cardiac complications. Nothing in his immediate family indicated any comparable spans either.

They pointed to acromegaly as an alternative, pointing to hand stiffness and the association between acromegaly and melanoma. They conceded that photographs from the 1920s and a 1925 portrait don’t show its coarse facial features, but later photographs, they argued, give credence to their theory.

Hektoen International notes there’s no photographic or historical evidence for either condition.

Rachmaninoff’s Death From Melanoma and His Farewell to His Hands

Melanoma ended Sergei Rachmaninoff’s 1942-43 tour after a recital in Knoxville. He passed away in Beverly Hills on March 28, 1943, four days before his 70th birthday. According to Ramachandran and Aronson’s paper in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, when cancer was diagnosed, he looked at his hands and whispered, “My dear hands… Farewell, my poor hands.”