“Bridge Over Troubled Water” grew out of a gospel record and a line made up on the spot by its singer. The record in question is the Swan Silvertones’ 1959 single “Mary Don’t You Weep,” later named to the Library of Congress’s National Recording Registry.
The lead singer, Claude Jeter, improvised the line “I’ll be a bridge over deep water if you trust in my name.” This was the spark for Simon & Garfunkel’s song.
How Paul Simon Built ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’ Around Gospel Piano
Paul Simon wrote the song on guitar, then moved it to piano to enhance the gospel influence and fit Art Garfunkel’s voice, according to Smooth Radio’s history of the recording. He hired session pianist Larry Knechtel to get the exact gospel piano sound he’d envisioned.
By the same account, Simon originally wrote “Bridge Over Troubled Water” in G major, but arranger Jimmie Haskell shifted it to E-flat. Joe Osborn played two bass parts, one high and one low, Hal Blaine recorded his drum parts in an echo chamber, and there are strings in the third verse.
Simon conceived the song as a small hymn. Garfunkel and co-producer Roy Halee thought it needed to be bigger, and talked him into writing a third verse, the”sail on, silver girl” section, which Simon felt sat awkwardly against the rest.
Why Art Garfunkel Sang the Lead on ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’
Paul Simon told Art Garfunkel to sing “Bridge Over Troubled Water” alone, in the “white choirboy way.” However, Garfunkel liked Simon’s falsetto on the demo, and urged him to take the vocal himself.
Simon refused, so Garfunkel ended up carrying the lead by himself. Simon added harmony only in the final stanza. The single reached No. 1 on February 28, 1970, and kept the position for six weeks.
How Paul Simon Reclaimed ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’ at His 2018 Farewell Concert
As the relationship between Simon & Garfunkel frayed, the former became resentful of the latter’s performance of “Bridge Over Troubled Water.” He’d sit off to the side of the stage while crowds cheered Garfunkel’s performance and thought the song was his.
On September 22, 2018, at his farewell concert in Flushing Meadows Corona Park in Queens, Simon introduced the song by saying he’d given it away and hadn’t sung it for a long time, then added: “I’m going to reclaim my lost child.” The arrangement he played was starker than the original.
How Paul Simon Credited Claude Jeter and the Swan Silvertones
Paul Simon also acknowledged the song’s other source. He hired Claude Jeter, the gospel original’s singer and founder of Swan Silvertones, to sing on his 1973 album “There Goes Rhymin’ Simon.” He also gave him $1,000 for the inspiration that led to the creation of “Bridge Over Troubled Water” and its great success.