“Riders on the Storm” closes The Doors‘ “L.A. Woman”, and for a track that runs more than seven minutes on the album, it rests on a short keyboard riff that Ray Manzarek came up with. One note in that riff gives the song much of its color. A lot of the menace people hear in it was added later, at the mixing desk.

How “Ghost Riders in the Sky” Became “Riders on the Storm”

The song grew, as so many from that era did, out of a jam. Robby Krieger told Uncut that the band was playing “(Ghost) Riders in the Sky,” the old cowboy standard, when Jim Morrison started fooling around with the title. In the same piece, Manzarek said he proposed the bassline and the piano part, and that the jazzy feel was his idea. On the original demo, the band cut at Sunset Sound, Manzarek played the bass line himself on a piano bass.

That demo didn’t win over producer Paul Rothchild. Engineer Bruce Botnick told Rolling Stone that Rothchild put his head in his hands and dismissed it as “cocktail jazz.” Rothchild left the project, and The Doors recorded the album with Botnick in their own rehearsal space, mostly live to tape over six days.

For those sessions, they brought in Jerry Scheff, who was on a break from Elvis Presley’s touring band. Krieger told Uncut that Scheff simply played what Manzarek had been playing with his left hand, and he credited that for how distinctive the line sounds: “It’s not something a bass player would come up with.” In this piano/vocal arrangement, the bass part goes back to the pianist’s left hand, which is where Manzarek had it to begin with.

The Note That Makes It Dorian

Music theorist Nicole Biamonte lists the main riff of “Riders on the Storm” as one of her examples of the Dorian i to IV progression in an appendix of pop songs for theory teachers, part of the 2011 teaching anthology she edited, Pop-Culture Pedagogy in the Music Classroom. Dorian is the natural minor scale with one change: the sixth degree is raised a half step. In E natural minor, the sixth note is C. In E Dorian, it’s C-sharp.

The song sits in E, so i to IV here means E minor to A major. That C-sharp is what makes the move possible, because it’s the third of the A major chord. Lower it back to C, and the same move becomes E minor to A minor, which is what the ordinary natural minor scale would give you. E minor is still home base in the Dorian version, so the song never stops sounding minor. The A major chord just lifts it a little every time it comes around. To my ear, that small lift is a big part of why “Riders” feels restless, and why it never quite sinks into gloom.

The MuseScore arrangement writes that move as Em to A/E, which is an A major chord with E kept in the bass, and it keeps coming back through the verses. Not every bar is Dorian, though. The arrangement also uses an A minor chord in places. That’s the iv chord of E natural minor, and it carries the plain C.

If there’s a keyboard nearby, play E minor to A major, then E minor to A minor, and listen to what happens on the second chord. That’s where Dorian and natural minor part ways.

The Thunder and Whisper Added in Bruce Botnick’s Mix

The other half of the song’s character is how patiently it unfolds. “Riders” leaves a lot of room for the instruments, and the score reflects that. Even as a piano/vocal arrangement, the score carries cues from the recording: it marks out a guitar solo, and after the coda sign, there’s a long section labeled “Fender Rhodes solo.” A lot of the tension on the record comes from what got layered on top.

Botnick’s own description backs that up. “When we first recorded ‘Riders on the Storm,’ it was a nice, light song,” he told Mix, and he credits the mixing sessions with pulling it together. That’s where the storm came in. Elektra had a set of sound effects discs, including one with rain and thunder, and Botnick ran it from a separate stereo tape under the mix because every track on the eight-track master was already used. He insists the thunderclaps landed where they did by pure luck. John Densmore remembers it differently, telling Rolling Stone that Botnick had extra thunder cued up so they could drop a clap wherever they wanted.

The storm even made it into the notation. The MuseScore arrangement opens with a marking for rain and thunder effects, and the same marking shows up again at the very end.

The whisper came out of the same mix sessions. Densmore told Uncut the idea was his: he suggested to Botnick that Morrison go back in and record a second pass of the lyrics in a whisper. Botnick has claimed it too, and he has told Mix that the two of them now share the credit. Densmore said in the same Uncut piece that you don’t really hear it unless you know it’s there. Manzarek added that the whispered vocal on the outro was the last singing Morrison ever did in a studio.

Morrison was already living in Paris by the time “L.A. Woman” came out in April 1971. The single version of “Riders on the Storm” entered the charts on July 3, the day he died there, and eventually reached #14.